Review · FISHING
Half day Deep sea/light tackle fishing charters
The fish do not follow a schedule. This private Nassau charter gives you four hours on the water with choices that include deep sea trolling for mahi, wahoo, and tuna, plus deep dropping and light tackle fishing. I like the private boat for up to four people and the fact that gear, bait, ice, soft drinks, and water are included. The main caution is simple: rough water and slow fishing can turn a dream catch into a demanding afternoon.
I also like the choice of morning or afternoon departures. That makes this easier to fit around a Nassau hotel stay, cruise schedule, or another island activity. Still, fishing is fishing. A previous poor outing involved choppy water and a crew member who was not very encouraging, so you should book this for time on the sea and a real chance at fish, not a promised haul.
In This Review
- Key points to know before booking
- Setting out from Bay Street in Nassau
- Choosing between trolling, deep dropping, and light tackle
- What the four-hour boat time really gives you
- Equipment, bait, drinks, and what you should bring
- Is $920 a fair price for four people?
- Who will enjoy this private Nassau charter?
- Handling a rough day on the water
- Booking, timing, and cancellation details
- Should you book the Bluefinn242 charter?
- FAQ
- Where does the fishing charter start and end?
- How long is the fishing excursion?
- How many people can join the private charter?
- What types of fishing are available?
- Which fish might I target?
- Are fishing equipment and bait included?
- Are drinks included, and can I bring alcohol?
Key points to know before booking

- Private boat for up to four: Your group has the activity to itself, with no unrelated passengers sharing the trip.
- Three fishing styles available: Choose deep sea trolling, deep dropping, light tackle, or a combination of those options.
- Target species include mahi, wahoo, and tuna: The exact catch depends on conditions and what is biting.
- Equipment and bait are supplied: You do not need to bring fishing tackle for this outing.
- Two departure windows: Choose approximately 8:30 AM to 12:30 PM or 1:00 PM to 5:00 PM.
- The cost makes more sense with four people: At $920 per group, the effective price is $230 per person when the boat is full.
Setting out from Bay Street in Nassau
The trip starts at Baoilco Limited on Bay Street in Nassau and returns to the same meeting point. That return arrangement matters because you do not need to plan a separate ride from another marina at the end of the charter.
The listed operating hours provide two useful blocks: 8:30 AM to 12:30 PM and 1:00 PM to 5:00 PM. The morning trip gives you the cooler part of the day and leaves your afternoon open. The afternoon trip lets you sleep later or spend the morning sightseeing before heading to the boat.
You should allow enough time to reach Bay Street without cutting it close. The meeting point is near public transportation, which helps if you are staying elsewhere in Nassau. The supplied information does not specify hotel pickup, so you should plan to reach the meeting point on your own.
This is a private activity, which changes the feel of the trip. You are not adapting to a large group’s pace or sharing the boat with strangers. If your party includes a serious angler and a first-timer, the private setup also gives you more room to choose how much time to spend on each fishing method.
More Fishing Trips in New Providence Island:
- Private Snorkeling or Fishing from Nassau – 31ft Sitting Pretty
★ 5.0 · 92 reviews - Private Snorkeling And Fishing Activity
★ 5.0 · 62 reviews - Private Speed Boat for Snorkeling or Fishing in Nassau – 34ft
★ 5.0 · 53 reviews
Choosing between trolling, deep dropping, and light tackle

The most useful feature here is the choice of fishing styles. You can focus on one method or combine them, depending on conditions and your group’s interests.
Deep sea trolling is the option aimed at fish such as mahi, wahoo, and tuna. The boat works offshore water while lines are presented for larger, faster fish. This is the choice for you if the main goal is the excitement of a strong strike and the possibility of bringing in a notable catch.
Trolling can also test your patience. It is active in bursts, but there is no guarantee that a fish will take the bait during four hours. A calm day with little action is part of the honest fishing equation.
Deep dropping uses lines sent to deeper water. The supplied information does not specify the exact depth, species, or equipment used for this part of the trip, so you should ask the crew what is working that day. It can be a useful change of pace if trolling is quiet, but the exact plan will depend on sea conditions and the crew’s judgment.
Light tackle offers a more hands-on style of fishing. It may suit you if you prefer a lighter rod and more direct involvement rather than waiting on offshore trolling lines. Again, the type and size of fish available are not guaranteed, so think of light tackle as a fishing method choice, not a promise of constant action.
The option to combine methods is especially useful for a four-hour charter. Your group could try trolling, then switch to another approach if the conditions or bite make that sensible. Since this is not a fixed sightseeing route, the fishing plan can be shaped around the day.
What the four-hour boat time really gives you

A four-hour charter sounds generous, but the clock includes more than the moment a line enters the water. You will meet the crew, get aboard, receive equipment, and move to the fishing area before the main action begins. At the end, the boat must return to Bay Street.
That still leaves a practical half day for fishing. The short format works well if you want a taste of offshore angling without committing to a full-day trip. It is also easier on a mixed group, where one person may be keen to fish all day while another wants time for Nassau’s other activities.
The private format helps you make those hours count. If one approach is not working, you can discuss changing methods rather than waiting for a group decision. The available information does not promise a specific route, fishing ground, or minimum amount of time spent at each method, so treat the day’s plan as flexible.
Your best chance of enjoying the outing comes from arriving with the right expectation. This is a chance to fish for mahi, wahoo, tuna, and other species. It is not a guaranteed catch package. One disappointing outing involved choppy water, and the people aboard felt the crew did not offer enough encouragement. That is a useful warning for anyone booking around a bucket-list fishing goal: the sea can be rough, and the fish can refuse to cooperate.
Equipment, bait, drinks, and what you should bring

The price includes all fishing gear and bait. That is a major convenience, especially if you are visiting Nassau and do not want to pack rods, tackle, or bait for a single outing.
Bottled water, ice, and soft drinks are also included. You can keep the basic cost easier to manage because you do not need to buy those items separately for the boat.
Alcoholic beverages are not included. If you want to drink alcohol, the supplied details do not say that it is permitted or that the crew provides it, so you should check with Bluefinn242 before bringing anything aboard.
The information provided does not list clothing, sun protection, meals, or personal fishing licenses. I would confirm any special requirements before departure rather than assume they are covered. You should also ask about what to bring for the weather, especially since choppy conditions have affected at least one outing.
The crew is described as professional, and the boat as comfortable and well equipped. Those are helpful signs, but the available details do not identify the boat model, seating arrangement, onboard facilities, or exact crew names. If those details matter to you, ask before booking.
A few more New Providence Island days to weigh up
- Pirate Jeep Sightseeing Adventure!
★ 5.0 · 1,307 reviews - Swimming Pigs and Private Beach Club Escape
★ 4.5 · 1,238 reviews - Nassau: Swimming Pigs And Snorkel With Turtles
★ 5.0 · 651 reviews - Bahamas Adventure: Pigs, Reef, Turtles, and Beach with Lunch
★ 5.0 · 640 reviews
Is $920 a fair price for four people?

The listed price is $920 per group of up to four people. With four people sharing the boat, that works out to $230 each. With three people, it becomes about $307 per person. With two, it is $460 each, and a solo booking would carry the full group price unless the operator offers another arrangement.
The value is strongest when you fill all four places. You are paying for a private charter rather than a shared trip, plus fishing equipment, bait, bottled water, ice, and soft drinks. That makes the price easier to justify for a small group that wants control over the fishing plan.
The value is weaker if your party has only one or two people and mainly wants a quick look at fishing. In that case, a shared excursion, if available elsewhere, might cost less. This charter’s advantage is privacy and flexibility, not a low per-person rate.
You should also weigh the uncertainty of the catch. The price does not buy a guaranteed mahi, wahoo, or tuna. It buys boat time, crew support, equipment, and access to several fishing approaches. If you can enjoy the outing even when the fish are scarce, the cost may feel reasonable. If landing a particular fish is the only acceptable result, you should think carefully before paying a premium private rate.
Who will enjoy this private Nassau charter?

I would consider this a good fit for a small group of up to four with a shared interest in fishing. It works especially well for friends or family members who want to spend a half day together without adding unrelated people to the boat.
It also suits a mixed-experience party. A first-time angler can use the supplied gear, while a more experienced person can ask about trolling, deep dropping, or light tackle. The range of options gives the crew more ways to shape the outing.
The morning departure is useful if you want the rest of the day free. The afternoon departure is better if you prefer a slower start or have plans in Nassau earlier. Both options return to the original meeting point.
I would be more cautious if someone in your group has a very specific bucket-list goal, such as catching one particular species. The activity offers a chance to target several fish, but it does not promise a catch. I would also think twice if anyone gets uncomfortable in rough water, since sea conditions can affect both comfort and fishing success.
Service animals are allowed, and the activity is near public transportation. Most people can participate, according to the supplied information, but you should still share any mobility or medical concerns with the operator before booking.
Handling a rough day on the water

Fishing charters depend on weather, sea conditions, and the behavior of fish. A previous outing was affected by choppy water, and the person who had hoped to deep sea fish felt discouraged by the crew’s response. The operator explained that some days produce poor fishing, which is true, but that does not erase the importance of good communication aboard.
Before leaving Bay Street, I would ask the crew what conditions look like, which method they recommend, and how willing they are to switch tactics. That small conversation can help set expectations and make the four hours feel more organized.
You should also understand that a private trip does not automatically mean a custom luxury service. It means only your group participates. The crew still controls the boat and fishing plan, and the day’s conditions may limit the choices.
The strongest approach is to treat the trip as a chance to learn and fish in Bahamian waters, with a possible catch as the reward. That mindset protects the day from becoming a disappointment if the water turns rough or the bite slows.
Booking, timing, and cancellation details

Confirmation is provided at booking. The activity operates daily within the listed morning and afternoon time blocks, from July 18, 2019 through November 25, 2026.
You can cancel for a full refund if you do so at least 24 hours before the experience’s start time. Cancellations made less than 24 hours before departure are not refunded, and changes within that same period are not accepted. The cut-off uses Nassau local time, so keep that in mind if you are booking from another time zone.
Because this is a private charter priced by group, confirm the total number of people before you pay. If your party shrinks, the cost per person rises sharply.
Should you book the Bluefinn242 charter?
Book it if you have up to four people, want a private boat, and value the freedom to try trolling, deep dropping, light tackle, or a mix of all three. The included gear and bait make it simple, while the morning and afternoon choices fit neatly into a Nassau visit.
I would book with realistic expectations. You may get a shot at mahi, wahoo, tuna, or other fish, but no responsible fishing charter can promise that the fish will bite. Ask about current sea conditions and the planned fishing method before departure, especially if this is a once-in-a-lifetime outing for someone in your group.
For a full party of four, the $920 price is easier to defend because you are sharing a private experience and its included supplies. For one or two people, the cost is harder to justify unless privacy matters a great deal. The right reason to book is the chance to spend four focused hours fishing with your own group, not a guaranteed trophy at the rail.
FAQ
Where does the fishing charter start and end?
It starts at Baoilco Limited on Bay Street in Nassau, The Bahamas. The activity ends back at the same meeting point.
How long is the fishing excursion?
The charter lasts approximately four hours.
How many people can join the private charter?
The price covers a private group of up to four people. Only your group participates in the activity.
What types of fishing are available?
You can choose deep sea trolling, deep dropping, light tackle, or a combination of these options.
Which fish might I target?
The experience names mahi, wahoo, and tuna, along with other fish species. A specific catch is not guaranteed.
Are fishing equipment and bait included?
Yes. All fishing gear and bait are included in the price.
Are drinks included, and can I bring alcohol?
Bottled water, ice, and soft drinks are included. Alcoholic beverages are not included.
Just added around New Providence Island
- Swim with Famous Pigs at Rose Island★ 5.0 · 2 reviews
- 5-Course Wine Luncheon at Graycliff Restaurant★ 4.5 · 6 reviews
- Private Beach Day / 50ft Sun Seeker or 33ft Boat / 1-10 Guests★ 5.0 · 5 reviews
- Vacation Photographer in Nassau★ 5.0 · 2 reviews
- Unlimited Water Sports Package★ 3.0 · 3 reviews
- Nassau Trike Site and Beach Tour★ 5.0 · 2 reviews
- Short Story Telling of Tellabration, Bahamas Through The Ages★ 4.5 · 6 reviews
- Swimming Pigs & ATV Tour★ 5.0 · 4 reviews
Fishing, compared.

Private Snorkeling or Fishing from Nassau – 31ft Sitting Pretty
Read our review →
Private Speed Boat for Snorkeling or Fishing in Nassau – 34ft
Read our review →
Private Snorkeling or Fishing in Nassau – 55ft Cocorijo
Read our review →
Private Snorkeling or Fishing Charter in Nassau – 38ft Free Time
Read our review →
Private Snorkeling, Fishing, and Swimming with Pigs
Read our review →
Crystal Bay Exclusive Private Exuma Boating & Fishing Excursions
Read our review →
Private Bahamas Half-Day Fishing Tour from New Providence
Read our review →Browse the lists this tour appears in

